6 Comments
User's avatar
Mike X Cohen, PhD's avatar

Very nice piece, thanks. Science is indeed hard (I quit my successful neuroscience prof job a few years, for several reasons including some you hinted at), and biology is particularly hard because it's so complex. Small samples preclude significance for all but the most trivial effects, and huge sample sizes often have little practical value -- e.g., if it takes 100k people to show some effect at p<.05, then I'm not sure it's a meaningful effect that individuals should be focusing on.

Anyway, good that you moved on to something you find more meaningful in your N=1 sample ;)

Alex Plesa's avatar

"I think I’d end up spending years or decades of my life on something irrelevant. Instead, I wanted to work in a field with faster experiments and a higher likelihood of eventually discovering objective truth." I can totally understand the feeling, yet if no one works on the problem, how can we make progress?

What would you like to see in the aging field to make you come back to study "one of the most exciting open problems in biology"?

Devon Stork's avatar

I don't think my answer should apply to everybody. I decided I didn't want to work in aging because I didn't have the risk tolerance for it. But I'm glad there are people who do!

To answer your question, the key is tools. Better tools and assays to produce better data will be needed. Some of those are aging-focused, like developing better epigenetic clocks and biochemical assays, but others are aging-agnostic, such as whole-cell models, single-cell sequencing & better cell-state & signaling-network reporters.

Biology as a discipline has improved so much in both what it can measure and what it can perturb in the last few years/decade/decades that if I were starting my degree now, I might come to a different answer. I wouldn't be doing a B-gal assay, I would be doing transcriptomics or epigenetics.

Alex Plesa's avatar

I didn't mean to imply your answer applies to everyone. I was saying that I can relate to it, and that if we don't figure out how to address concerns like yours, we'll have fewer and fewer people in the field.

I agree with you with respect to the tools being necessary, but I'd go even further and say that they will likely come from outside the field. Steve Horvath wasn't your traditional aging researcher when he discovered DNAm correlates really well with age (https://erictopol.substack.com/i/147976058/serendipity). As for the whole-cell models, despite the advances of our read and write capabilities in bio, I still think we're a bit too limited to develop useful models for controlling biology.

Also, cool work on engineering the Mars microbes!

Paul Orwin's avatar

Hi Devon, I am sorry to put this in a chat like this, but I couldn’t find another way to contact you - I’ll also send a note to the Pioneer Labs email. I’m a fellow HMC alum (class of 1995), a microbiologist, and a Bio prof at University of the Pacific. I’d like to get in touch, so if you could please establish email contact porwin@pacific.edu I’d appreciate it.

Yuuki Hosokawa's avatar

Great writing! Loved reading it as someone that works at a longevity biotech and appreciates cautious optimism in aging research.